Collings Research Logo

Professional Audio and Video

Previous Blogs

11/11/2015

The state of Dolby C


Dolby C synonymous with consumer tape decks and broadcast decks was the last attempt to make tape more palatable and provide an illusion of increased quality and dynamics.
Dolby C type in effect made yet more compatibility problems, with tracking and frequency response issues that were all instilled even in the highest quality components. It always seemed that when encoding Dolby C recording, it could never ever be played correctly on another machine; probably why no pre-recorded tapes ever bothered with this compression type. Considering the random adoption of Dolby B and the general complaint that it made everything sound dull, Dolby C would mean this would be several times worse. Hence, manufacturers of pre-recorded medium could see more returns than they would be happy with due to this respect.
As most of the readers of this would undoubtedly have sampled the delights of compact cassettes, noise reduction in conclusion does have its merits. The narrow tape of cassettes does exhibit a very narrow band of high frequency noise that isn’t overall pleasant to listen in quiet sections. It seems that Dolby C was an attempt to create a new home recording market and inspire greater sales of ever more expensive equipment advertising confidence head playback and direct motor drive and the like, even when the music industry was at its peak in stressing illegal home taping.
Therefore, Dolby C in home recording was flawed due to the technical limitations of the home recording medium. The only true success of C type was in the professional range where higher linear tape speeds and better calibration meant that it could succeed and impact least on the recorded material. Many professional implementations of C were out-board types for increased flexibility meaning the inclusion of Dolby tones and levels for better compatibility. The non-inclusion of the Dolby level signal in home recording equipment aided the compatibility problems.
With the steady improvement in tape technology, material could be recorded at higher levels and tape that exhibited low self-noise. This in effect negated the importance of Dolby C, and allowing the less invasive Dolby B to be used in its place, particularly important for very low tape speeds.
So, when it comes to digitising Dolby encoded medium of unknown origins, it may be beneficial to sample the non-decoded tape and re-encode later so no actual information is lost. Improvements in single-ended noise reduction can actually mean Dolby decoding is unnecessary for some material if accuracy is not paramount, and the end effect can be sometimes be better than the original decoding.

 

12/11/2012

We acquired an old Sony SL-C7 betamax recorder for restoration purposes and were keen to compare the results with our production Sanyo VTC-6500. The SL-C7 required a lot of work; all new belts, a proper clean up, a new pinch roller, a new idler conversion kit (for proper spooling). Once the mechanics were done, the picture was surprisingly good which certainly looked every bit as good as the VTC-6500. However, when listening to the audio it was evident that there was high wow and flutter. The usual culprit was the threading motor, also doubling as the capstan motor (this sounds bad, but in fact doesn't seem to affect the tracking stability). The motor was extremely stiff to turn and even though a generous dose of alcohol freed it up, it still exhibited the same flutter problem as probably the bearings were completely worn out. The only solution was to put in a new replacement, and when this was done, the wow and flutter problem went away, and also the slow threading was much improved. It's unfortunate that this motor has to do threading as well, as this must reduce the overall life and put extra strain on its bearings. There is some light flickering in the video output, so some electronic diagnostics is required, probably the usual caps and/or oscillator instabilities. Also, ALL the timer switches were stuck so with what appears to be the last remaining stock, some of the major switches were replaced; not as though this is required for video playback, it is still nice to actually set the timer and clock! We have a new ACE and video head to fit at a later date which should improve performance as the current video head looks as though it has had a hard life!

29/07/2012

When acquiring our Sony decks BVU-950P and BVW-75P, they had bad capacitors particularly in the audio section. The BVU-950P experienced low level buzzing in playback, and the BVW-75P electro caps were visibly showing signs of rupturing. Even considering the age of these decks, it must be due to the placement of the boards as the audio board is placed at the back between the cooling fans therefore does not receive the same ventilation as other boards. All caps were replaced, and problem solved.

20/07/2012

The U-Matic BVU-800P is a high band player that is a work-in-progress. A grinding noise was noticed when the drum was rotating, so a lower drum was duly found and replaced. However it turns out that a wire was fouling the lower drum due to a clip missing, and being pressed against the power supply. However, it turns out the that the original bearings are slightly audible compared to the replacement, so the original was probably past it's best anyway.

Changing over the lower drum of our BVU-800P.

bvu-800 lower drum change